x
Breaking News
More () »

Back to Bardstown: Conspiracy to Murder | Ep. 2

Two more men are charged in Crystal Rogers' death, but an attorney argues one of the suspects should be immune from prosecution.

BARDSTOWN, Ky. — Three months after Joseph Lawson is arrested in the death of Crystal Rogers, his father, 53-year-old Steve Lawson is taken into police custody.

Like his son, Lawson was charged with conspiracy to commit murder and tampering with physical evidence. His charges stem from an incident over the Fourth of July weekend in 2015. The same weekend Rogers vanished.

PREVIOUS EPISODE: Shock and Confusion | Ep. 1 

NEXT EPISODE: The Truth Will Set You Free | Ep. 3

According to Lawson’s attorney, who is a well-known lawyer in the area, the arrest came as a complete surprise due to his client’s cooperation with the authorities.

LISTEN TO EPISODE TWO:

Episode two will be available to stream on Spotify and Apple Podcasts on Tuesday, April 2.

Conspiracy to Murder

Steve Lawson was arrested in southern Indiana while visiting his mother. 

As police worked to extradite him back to Nelson County, WHAS11 Investigative Reporter Shay McAlister tracked down his attorney to learn more about Lawson’s connection to Rogers’ case.

Although Lavit didn’t elaborate much on the late-night phone call between Houck and Steve on the night Rogers disappeared in 2015, he said Steve’s son, Joseph Lawson, was “extremely involved.”

RELATED: Attorney: Prosecution could face ‘trouble’ convicting suspects in Crystal Rogers case if relying on Lawson testimonies

According to Lavit, Joseph Lawson is the answer to one of the biggest questions surrounding Rogers’ disappearance: How did the Bardstown mother’s car end up alongside the Bluegrass Parkway, all her belongings untouched, just days after she was reported missing?

Credit: WHAS11 News
Thursday's court hearing was the first time both Lawsons had seen each other since their arrests. | Feb. 8, 2024

Lavit also spoke of a “transactional immunity” given to Steve Lawson in exchange for his cooperation with investigators. He said there were dozens of interviews leading up to the arrest.

Despite those claims, Lawson was arrested and charged while the investigation continued.

As police continued searching for answers in Nelson County, a discreet property search was underway and another arrest would soon grip the small town.

On a warm September morning, the man named the prime suspect in his girlfriend’s disappearance eight years prior was working on a construction site when undercover officers placed him in handcuffs.

RELATED: Why did Brooks Houck have three mugshots taken in Crystal Rogers death investigation?

Credit: WHAS11 News
Crystal Rogers' former boyfriend, Brooks Houck, has been charged in connection to her 2015 disappearance.

A neighbor spotted the arrest, took a picture, and the news spread like wildfire:

Brooks Houck arrested, charged in the death of Crystal Rogers, held on a $10 million bond.

Houck’s arrest is only the beginning of a lengthy court process, but soon prosecutors will shock Nelson County once again with bombshell information linking Crystal Rogers’ death to another unsolved murder.

Episode three of "Back to Bardstown" will be released on the WHAS11 YouTube channel on Monday, April 8. It will be released on Spotify and Apple Podcasts on Tuesday, April 9.

Make it easy to keep up-to-date with more stories like this. Download the WHAS11 News app now. For Apple or Android users.

Have a news tip? Email assign@whas11.com, visit our Facebook page or Twitter feed.

   

Before You Leave, Check This Out