Breaking News
More () »

'The system fails families': Chief Shields discusses low homicide clearance rate as families grieve

For the 22 Louisville Metro detectives working homicides, the cases are piling up.

LOUISVILLE, Ky. — With every shooting in Louisville, a family is changed forever. Violence leaves families like Beverly Taylor’s torn apart.

“People say it’s going to get easy,” Taylor said. “It doesn’t get easy.”

Before May 2, 2019, Taylor said she talked to her older brother, Nathaniel Hill, every day. In an instant, that changed.

Taylor said Hill was breaking up a fight outside Wayside Christian Mission when he was killed.

After the pain of identifying her brother’s body, Taylor said old photos can be difficult to see.

“It’s just hard, it’s real hard,” Taylor said. “A lot of deaths is just senseless and when’s it going to stop? It was awful.”

More than two years later, no one has been convicted. It’s a situation that’s all too familiar for families in Louisville.

This year, Louisville Metro Police said they have had 60 criminal homicides. Only 19 have been closed.

That means for some of the most violent crimes in the city, for every suspect arrested, two or more are walking free.

Louisville Metro Police Chief Erika Shields said she recognizes a homicide clearance rate of about 31% is low.

“Oh, it’s low and it’s not what the homicide unit wants it to be,” Shields said. “There are other factors driving that and they more than anyone want the rate to go up.”

Shields said other factors driving the low clearance rate include unprecedented levels of violence, distrust of police and fear of retaliation.

Open homicide cases with LMPD date back to the early 2000s. For the 22 detectives working homicides, the cases are piling up. For families like Hill's, patience is running low.

“The system fails families, and I’m a family that they failed,” Taylor said. “It’s no more birthdays, it’s no more nothing, he’s just gone at this point.”

The goal from LMPD is to get that homicide clearance rate closer to the national average, which is about 60%. Then eventually Shields said she wants to get Louisville to 70% of homicides being solved.

The plan for doing that is being engaged in the community, being proactive versus reactive, getting out of squad cars and into neighborhoods and hiring more people. Right now, the police department is short hundreds of officers.

Contact reporter Kristin Pierce at kpierce@whas11.com. Follow her on Twitter and Facebook.

RELATED: LMPD chief breaks down how Louisville's proposed budget would affect police, public safety

RELATED: 'Miscommunication' | Louisville police chief explains barricading of west Louisville Kroger during Derby weekend

Make it easy to keep up-to-date with more stories like this. Download the WHAS11 News app now. For Apple or Android users.

Have a news tip? Email assign@whas11.com, visit our Facebook page or Twitter feed.

Before You Leave, Check This Out