Share this article:
Print

I-Team Investigation: Inside the multi-million dollar business of dog auctions - Part 2

Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

by WHAS11 News

WHAS11.com

Posted on May 26, 2010 at 6:04 PM

Updated Wednesday, May 26 at 6:50 PM

Louisville, KY (WHAS11)  - Puppy auctions are something many puppy mill operators and pet store owners don't want you to see.

WHAS11's Melanie Kahn went undercover to one of the auctions last weekend, where hundreds of dogs were sold. She and the crew did not leave empty-handed.

They were working with a rescue group called Luv 4 K9s, a group based out of Dayton, Ohio.

Together, they brought nine dogs home, which is all they could fit in the car.

On the way, they stopped at a veterinarian just outside Holmes County.

This is the conclusion of this WHAS11 Investigation.

Hundreds of dogs stacked up in wire crates, all waiting to be put on the auction block and sold to the highest bidder.

WHAS11’s hidden camera went inside the Buckeye Dog Auction in Farmerstown, Ohio.

Dog auctioning is a multi-million dollar national industry and it is legal in almost every state, including Kentucky, Indiana and Ohio. But animal rights groups say it's an inhumane practice that should be stopped.

The auction house WHAS11 visited is owned by Harold Neuhart. When WHAS11 confronted him and asked to speak to him, he refused and at one point, grabbed the camera.

After Neuhart refused an interview, WHAS11 News left the auction house, but not empty handed.

The volunteer who brought us into the auction bought nine dogs.

After leaving the auction house, WHAS11 and the volunteer went to Dr. Jeff Baranack, a veterinarian at the Oak Pointe Veterinary Care Clinic, in Dover, just outside of Holmes County.

For years, Dr. Baranack has worked with the Humane Society of America, helping dogs like the ones at auction.
   
When WHAS11 brought in the dogs, he agreed to examine and treat all of them for free.   

One by one, he carefully examined each dog, many were still afraid to come out of their carriers and a few shook in the doctor’s hands.

Some of the dogs WHAS11 brought in had minor problems; slight eye problems, ear infections and tooth problems.

Then others, like one little dachshund, known as #244, had bigger issues. She had a large bump on her back, requiring immediate treatment.

"Something that she hit her back against caused some bleeding and it clotted and what's left is a pocket of serum... We call it a seroma. That's such a large one on her back, that, to be honest when I feel it from the outside, it's probably been there a while.  There's some scaring around it, so in my opinion, it's been there a while," explained Dr. Baranack.

Others were living in such poor conditions, that they had ears infested with ear mites.

According to state law it is legal to breed puppies for commercial purposes, but it is illegal to treat them inhumanely or to keep them in unsanitary conditions.

"There’s a demand for puppies and where there's a demand, people will find a way to make a buck off of it," added Dr. Baranack.

According to Dr. Baranack, the people who make the most money are pet stores.

"You go into these pet stores and you see these cute little puppies you have to realize, great you want the puppy, but you're supporting a lifestyle," added Dr. Baranack.

This lifestyle and the industry continues to be one of the largest in the United States.
All nine of the dogs are well now.

Eight are living with either foster families or at the Luv 4 K9's Animal Rescue in Dayton, Ohio.
 
One dog did come back with WHAS11 and we have some photos of her.

The dachshund who suffered from the seroma on her back, the dog once known as #244, is now named Annabelle.

She was adopted by one of our photographers, Aron Pryor, who says she is doing well, and started wagging her tail for the first time Tuesday.

You can see photos of Annabelle and all the dogs from the auction in our photo gallery. If you are interested in adopting one of the dogs, you can find more information at Luv4K9s.com or by calling 937-974-7325.

If you'd like more information on dog auctions and the effort to ban them, visit the Coalition to Ban Dog Auctions Website.
 

Share this article:
Print

To add a comment, please register or login.

Leave your comment
1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

HTML is not allowed.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Comments: Displaying 1 - 12 of 12

fleaonthedog said on May 30, 2010 at 6:14 PM

Angola....We NEED some kind of a plan in place, whereby IF the USDA agent says (fat chance, right?!?!??!) these dogs must go, I am taking them, you are DONE breeding, here and NOW! the dogs would have a place to go. There isn't a county pound that could hold an additional 30 dogs, much less a hundred. (or more) And can you imagine the uproar, if dogs were seized and euthanized? THAT, I believe, is a primary reason there aren't seizures...no one can afford them (without calling in the HSUS or whoever) and oh would we prefer to take care of it locally, right?

44377319
Flag this comment

angolabulldog3 said on May 30, 2010 at 8:51 AM

An internal government report published May 22 says dogs are dying and living in horrific conditions due to lax government enforcement of large kennels known as puppy mills. The investigators visited 68 dog breeders and dog brokers in eight states that had been cited for at least one violation in the previous three years. On those visits, they found that first-time violators were rarely penalized, even for more serious violations, and repeat offenders were often let off the hook as well. The agency also gave some breeders a second chance to correct their actions even when they found animals dying or suffering, delaying confiscation of the animals. Within the APHIS Eastern Regional Office, the following *dealer facilities that were included as part of this audit: •12 - Sugardcreek, OH •13 - Sugarcreek, OH •16 - Millersburg, OH •17 - Millersburg, OH •18 - Millersburg, OH •19 - Millersburg, OH •20 - Millersburg, OH

44352024
Flag this comment

fleaonthedog said on May 30, 2010 at 12:55 AM

We all need to distinguish between hoarders and rescues. Hoarders (such as the woman in Trumbull County, the women in SW OH, Tiger Ranch, PA, and others) need to be identified, so that they can be stopped, and the animals be relieved of their suffering. It takes neighbors, average citizens, law enforcement, astute shelter workers, and other rescuers to find and identify hoarders. It seems there are likely a couple hundred good rescues for each hoarder. But, then, we don't know. The Witzman woman had her mother apparently bed bound in her own mess upstairs, one woman in SW OH had two dead dogs (and 4 live ones) in her bedroom. A common feature is having dead animals in freezers, rather than disposing of the carcasses. Hoarding is a whole 'nother issue beside 'rescue'.

44342629
Flag this comment

tellthetruth1001 said on May 27, 2010 at 10:40 PM

By the way I have not seen a dog sell for $20 for quite some time I have seen these groups pay top dollar for a breed female so their profits are better......This group you went undercover with will have the dogs on the net by Monday morning....They must have had to have a lot of training and vet care HUH...... Please if you want to correct something lets start with the rescue groups that abuse animals like the one in Trumbell County.....Oh ya you don't want top talk about that .... How about the Human Society of Akron shown throwing wait a second tossing cats into the dumpester..... Oh ya that ok its the rescues...... Please lets see a two sided story.......

44201104
Flag this comment

baumgak1 said on May 27, 2010 at 12:55 PM

The auction operators won't stop until legislation is put in place either to ban the auctions or to make stricter laws about kennels. The majority of people at these auctions are either other amish breeders or other puppy mill operators who are not concerned with the quality of breed they produce. The rescue groups that attend the auction typically do not bid against these people and are usually there for cast offs. For dogs that aren't wanted (older females, unproven males, etc) it is more common that a rescue would only pay $20. That's a small price to pay for freedom. They are not getting rich off of the rescue groups that come and get them. In the past there have been unwanted litters of puppies sold for 2 for $1.00. Occassionally, a rescue will bid on a dog that clearly needs out of there due to a health condition, etc. Sometimes, this results in an appropriate euthanasia performed by a veterinarian to stop the dog's suffering. (pyometra, broke bones, protuded bowel, etc)

44153934
Flag this comment

angolabulldog3 said on May 27, 2010 at 6:12 AM

Ohiodoglover: this rescue person - luv4k9s - has worked closely with animal advocates and local/state/federal authorities in helping to expose and address bad breeding operations. yes, she may have helped the investigative team put money back in the millers' pockets but the rescue of the nine dogs may help save hundreds and end these auctions altogether. it is helping the coalition to ban ohio dog auctions in their efforts to place a proposed law similar to the one in pa (statute 459-603) before the state legislators in january 2011.

44118979
Flag this comment

ohiodoglover said on May 26, 2010 at 10:15 PM

Buying these 9 dogs just put money right back into the breeders' and auction owner's hands. Some breeders bring certain breeds because they KNOW rescues will be there to "save" them. And the enabling of this horrid business continues...

44104224
Flag this comment

angolabulldog3 said on May 26, 2010 at 8:40 PM

There are many rescue people and reputable breeders who do not support the current puppy mill bill as amended. i am one of them. i also met many of the people at the rally who do not support the bill. someone mentioned that an alternative bill will be introduced in november and i hope that's a much better bill. what i do like about both bills is that there is a section which does include a ban on dog auctions.

44098079
Flag this comment

fleaonthedog said on May 26, 2010 at 8:17 PM

We have been asking the Coalition to Ban Ohio Dog Auctions to support a real puppy mill bill, also.

44096764
Flag this comment

angolabulldog3 said on May 26, 2010 at 6:56 PM

Dog auctions are a tragic embarrassment to Ohio and it's humane-minded citizens. The Coalition to Ban Ohio Dog Auctions has been asked if people should "buy" or "rescue" these dogs. We are asking for an all-out boycott of this event. We have studied the numbers from past auctions and believe that the dogs being offered at this auction are not necessarily mill cast-offs but were, in many cases, purposely bred to supply auction buyers, including rescue groups. Buying at the auction will simply mean that it will be profitable. If it is profitable, it will continue and more dogs will be bred for sale at future Ohio Dog Auctions. That said, we do understand compassion for the dogs being sold and know that there will be some who will buy. We understand both sides of the situation, and hope that in the long run, not buying will produce the best outcome to end these auctions altogether.

44091484
Flag this comment

angolabulldog3 said on May 26, 2010 at 6:54 PM

Dog auctions are a tragic embarrassment to Ohio and it's humane-minded citizens. The Coalition to Ban Ohio Dog Auctions has been asked if people should "buy" or "rescue" these dogs. We are asking for an all-out boycott of this event. We have studied the numbers from past auctions and believe that the dogs being offered at this auction are not necessarily mill cast-offs but were, in many cases, purposely bred to supply auction buyers, including rescue groups. Buying at the auction will simply mean that it will be profitable. If it is profitable, it will continue and more dogs will be bred for sale at future Ohio Dog Auctions. That said, we do understand compassion for the dogs being sold and know that there will be some who will buy. We understand both sides of the situation, and hope that in the long run, not buying will produce the best outcome to end these auctions altogether.

44091319
Flag this comment

ohioanimallover said on May 26, 2010 at 6:28 PM

I hope people realize that although the dogs were bought for the purpose of this investigation, it is not good to go to dog auctions to "save" dogs because in the process you are feeding the system and making it worse. If nobody buys from auctions, they will be stopped, just like not buying from pet stores.

44089384
Flag this comment